Finn confronts the power behind Founders Island, but will he ever return home to Ooo? 
After meeting his mother's consciousness, Finn is flabbergasted when his mother insists that he stays forever. Minerva showcases a simulation where Finn and Jake's ship is destroyed by the Guardian before they can leave in order to dissuade Finn from leaving. Meanwhile, Susan is still attempting to reignite Frieda's desire for exploration. Finn and Jake explain their lives in the Land of Ooo, but Minerva finds it too dangerous for Finn to live. To prove his point, Finn shows Minerva his memories, but Minerva remains adamant on Finn staying permanently. Finn claims he can convince the humans to leave, but Minerva undermines this effort.
Outside, Finn tries to convince the humans to grow out of their shell of fear, but the humans complain that it is too hard. Jake accompanies him in showcasing the wonders of Ooo: the magic, kingdoms made of candy, and depressed men. They proclaim that fear is needed for a person to grow, and the humans collectively rally in support of the idea. Susan overhears the commotion and brings Frieda outside. Upon hearing the speech, Frieda's fervor for exploration returns. The success of Finn's arguments make Minerva nervous, so she deploys her Minerva Bots to intervene. The Minerva Bots shoot a force field into the sky, threatening to upload the consciousness of everybody in the surrounding islands into the Better Reality software. While everybody is paralyzed by fear, Finn returns to his mother.
Minerva argues to Finn that he forced her hand, to which Finn bargains his consciousness to be uploaded into the Better Reality software in place of everybody. Minerva tries to explain that she is just helping everybody. Finn responds by showing Minerva his memories of helping people in Ooo. Minerva, convinced by what she saw, decides to let Finn go knowing that a chaotic world molded him into a helper like herself. The Minerva Bots disable the enveloping force field and stand down.
At the island's port, Finn invites the humans with him, but the humans generally decline due to the sudden decision to leave. Frieda accepts this invitation and travels with Susan. Frieda and Susan, from their Transport ship, lure the Guardian out of the water with a ship hologram while Finn and Jake climb into the Guardian's core to upload Minerva's consciousness, who orders the Guardian to finally stand down as their protector. Frieda and Susan part ways with Finn, Jake, and BMO and decide to make new memories together.
Aboard a freighter ship captained by BMO, Finn dons a Better Reality helmet, which transports him to his old domestic home in the island. He is greeted by Minerva's consciousness, and they share a parting hug. Finn asks if she is the same person after sacrificing her physical body and uploading her consciousness, to which she replies that she doesn't know for sure but feels like she is. Minerva disappears after the ship moves out of the island's signal range, leaving Finn alone in the virtual reality. Finn sheds a tear as he says goodbye.
Cameos in Finn's memories
- The Lich
- Giant Floating Mushroom
- Princess Bubblegum
- Flame Princess
- Huntress Wizard
- Ice King
- Earl of Lemongrab
- Magic Man
- Tiny Manticore
- Farmworld Finn
- The Comet
- Ancient Psychic Tandem War Elephant
- The episode's title seems to parallel season 7's "The Dark Cloud."
- It also fits because they are both the last episode of their respective miniseries.
- The final scene of this episode, where Finn sheds a single tear while saying "Goodbye" to his mother, is both a parallel and a stark contrast to the final scene of "The Invitation," where Finn happily removed his hat while sailing to the islands in Bubblegum's boat.
- The scene where Finn hugs Minerva in virtual reality and asks if it is truly his mother is similar to the Futurama episode "Game of Tones" where Fry speaks to his mother in her dream.
- The ship that Finn, Jake, and BMO use to get home to Ooo is nearly identical to the ship that the human survivors use in Stakes. It is likely that it is the same ship because it seems to be that the founders of the islands are the human survivors of the war.
- Finn is unharmed by two electric shocks (one after the first memory sequence, and another inside the Guardian), since he became electric-resistant in "Flute Spell."
- The first memory sequence consists of scenes from the following episodes:
- Susan punching Finn in "Reboot."
- Marceline with stakes in "Checkmate."
- Fern punching Finn in "Two Swords."
- Finn encountering the Lich in the citadel in "Escape from the Citadel."
- Giant Floating Mushroom in "Mama Said."
- Finn battling the possessed Princess Bubblegum in "Mortal Recoil."
- Finn kissing Flame Princess in "Burning Low."
- Finn and Jake hitching unto Princess Bubblegum's ship in "The Comet."
- Grob Gob Glob Grod colliding with Martin's ship in "Astral Plane."
- Finn's grass arm detaching in "Escape from the Citadel."
- The second memory sequence consists of scenes from the following episodes:
- Finn carrying the villagers in "The Visitor."
- Finn helping Huntress Wizard in "Flute Spell."
- Finn and Jake consoling Marceline in "Marceline The Vampire Queen."
- Finn consoling Fern in "Do No Harm."
- Finn and Jake consoling Ice King in "King's Ransom."
- Finn helping the Earl of Lemongrab in "The Mountain."
- Finn freeing Tiny Manticore in "Sons of Mars."
- Finn and Farmworld Finn using the Maid in "Crossover."
- Finn freeing the Comet from Orgalorg in "The Comet."
- Finn, Jake and the Ancient Psychic Tandem War Elephant in "Something Big."
- Finn, Jake, Starchy, Shelby, Neptr, Princess Bubblegum and Ice King rejoicing in "Don't Look."
- The beginning music of Baby's Building a Tower into Space is heard during Finn's speech.
- This episode was released for digital download and DVD on January 24, 2017.
- When the Guardian is decommissioned by Minerva's digital persona it allows the humans opportunity to travel from the island.