The Muffin Top theater is designed to look like a muffin on the inside, although it doesn't share this aspect inside the building. There is a ticket booth seen near the entrance, and there is an alleyway seen to the right of the building. The seats for the audience are metal folding chairs. The set for "Summer Showers" has yellow wallpaper and a green couch.
- There is a picture seen of Dr. Donut holding a skull, a reference to Hamlet.
- Woody, Ee-ow, Hairy Gummy, and the Spider Ghost all show up as non-speaking cameos, similar to there appearance in Ocarina.
- "Summer Showers" is the only play seen being performed in the building.