BMO and Marceline swap stories about their recent adventures.
- Finn (flashback)
- Jake (flashback; non-speaking)
- Lollipop Girl (flashback)
- Blue Tranch (flashback)
- Marceline's Mom (pictured, imagination; as Moon Lady)
- Blue Jay (flashback)
- Ted (flashback)
- The Blue Jay yelling "Whooooooooah!" is an homage to the character Mordecai from the series Regular Show. The Blue Jay was voiced by J.G. Quintel, who created the show and also voiced the aforementioned character. Additionally, he storyboarded the Adventure Time episode "Ocean of Fear."
- BMO is unaware that the vampires were wiped out six months prior, as BMO was not present in any episode of Stakes.
- Marceline's puppet show story seems to represent events that occurred before the Elements miniseries, with the potato curse representing the elemental changes that Ooo underwent, as well as the central characters being based on Marceline, Princess Bubblegum, and Patience St. Pim.
- This episode features special sequences by guest animators Alex Butera and Lindsay Small, who also worked on the guest animation in the episode "Beyond the Grotto."