Category talk:Candidates for deletion/Archives02

Jake's Family Sword

 * It is just another one of Finn's swords and they don't get individual articles. 23:52, May 4, 2012 (UTC)
 * I'm agree. It's not even that important for the actual plot.Afliador8 18:51, May 6, 2012 (UTC)
 * Well, it isn't "just" another one of Finn's swords. It has some history, being the family sword. I say we keep it. Sky  Monster 18:57, May 6, 2012 (UTC)
 * The sword isn't "just another" one of the swords, I agree. However, It IS another one of Finn's swords. Let's try not to diminish the demon blood sword as being equivalent to the katanas in "Slow Love."
 * Finn's golden sword and the root sword both are used for quite a while (with the demon blood sword probably to follow suit). We could give these swords that are used in multiple episodes articles that include appearance and uses, as well as whatever history is behind them. They might not be long articles, but these items are on their own certainly more significant than Taser for example. This seems like an acceptable solution as long as the information on the Finn's swords article is always kept brief. The other swords on the article - dagger, katana, adult sword etc. have no choice but to be brief, so for them to be mentioned in both places would be inherently redundant - both their subsection and their article would be all inclusive. This suggestion is that all swords mentioned in the aforementioned article should be no longer than two sentences with a picture, with the 'more important' swords having a link to their main article.
 * Alternatively, the Finn's swords article could just be all inclusive of all the swords. This is essentially the exact same argument as the merge of Axe-Bass. I think whatever agreement is reached should be applied to both, so I'm going to also go ahead and direct people talking about that here, and hopefully people can see how it applies to both... Flame Prince Finn 22:08, May 7, 2012 (UTC)


 * You've changed my vote. 12:47, May 8, 2012 (UTC)
 * Going to go ahead and pick a side. I think the root sword and golden sword deserve articles more than other objects. FPsig1.png Flame   Prince  Finn FPsig2.png 03:59, May 12, 2012 (UTC)
 * My opinion on this is similar to my opinion on the Axe Bass. FP Pony Flipped.png Saber Sworn FP Pony.png 04:29, May 12, 2012 (UTC)
 * Jake's Family Sword is an object that has a back story that might be showed in a featured episode. Unlike the other swords Finn owns, The sword being a family object. FP Pony Flipped.png Saber Sworn FP Pony.png 04:58, May 12, 2012 (UTC)


 * agreed Animaltamer7 09:13, May 12, 2012 (UTC)Animaltamer7Animaltamer7 09:13, May 12, 2012 (UTC)

Whatever. This sword seems to be more experienced or something.--Afliador8 00:38, May 15, 2012 (UTC)

Prince Gumball's Bedroom

 * This article needs to be merged with something, anything. Be it his own article, the Fionna and Cake episode article, the Fionna and Cake object article, wherever PB's bedroom's info is article, or whatever. It does not need to stand alone. 23:52, May 4, 2012 (UTC)
 * I merged with Prince Gumball's article. What you think?Afliador8 19:52, May 5, 2012 (UTC)

Jake's Subconscious
Taken from article's talk page. I can't decide if this should have its own article. However, the point that it is like "Football" is not a good one.

Football is a reflection, Jake's Subconscious moves independently. Furthermore, he SEEMS (key word) to think independently. He advises Jake to do things he wouldn't do otherwise, like wear a hat instead of crossing the river of junk. It is unclear if others can see him, but the Witch at least seems to - meaning he might be manifested in some real form, which would make him something Jake "summoned," though unintentionally.

We have articles for other aspects of Jake's imagination. To say this should be merged is kind of similar to saying every character that he imagined in Rainy Day Daydream should (not the exact same, I realize. I said similar. Jake is apparently the one one who can see it, he manifested it into reality himself, and it is sprung from his mind effortlessly).

I think there are good arguments for having it as a stand-alone article and also for merging. Shall we discuss? Flame Prince Finn 01:30, April 17, 2012 (UTC)


 * Perhaps he should be added to the Jake's imagination article, but I don't see how he could be given a full article to himself imo. [[Image:Shinx.png|link=User:felinoel|User Page]]  ƒel inoel  [[Image:Scraft.gif|link=Special:Contributions/Felinoel|Contributions]] . 18:38, April 23, 2012 (UTC)


 * Agree with Feli. It should be in jake's article.They seem to be the same character with different points of view.--Afliador8 02:55, May 5, 2012 (UTC)


 * Just because two characters are very similar doesn't mean they shouldn't have their own article if they are independent though. I was basically saying that Jake's subconscious acts not in unison with Jake, and in that sense could have his own article. As long as all the information stays with the merge, I see no problem with it. Flame Prince Finn May 7.


 * I was saying that it is because they are one character that they should be merged, not because they are two characters that are similar, also it would be preferable to me if you sign with four tildes or manually sign your name like I assume you did above and then use five tildes for the proper date stamp.
 * That date stamp is kinda needed for waiting four days. =b 12:50, May 8, 2012 (UTC)
 * I had this vague and unintelligent assumption that four tildes wouldn't do a signature in source mode... You're probably right. I was considering it as roughly logically equivalent to the Shadow Horse, but they are totally different situations. I already voted merge and I'm staying with that. Flame Prince Finn 17:43, May 8, 2012 (UTC)
 * Source mode? 18:19, May 8, 2012 (UTC)